All insights

Beyond the numbers: what really makes a publisher's audience valuable?

I started my career in media sales at The Observer, working in the magazine team, where one phrase was drummed into us almost daily: “An ad a day keeps the P45 away.” Decades later, I still feel a slight shiver when I hear those words. Behind that brutal sales mantra was a relentless focus on the fundamentals of advertising: circulation, coverage and reach...

Beyond the numbers: what really makes a publisher's audience valuable?

I started my career in media sales at The Observer, working in the magazine team, where one phrase was drummed into us almost daily: “An ad a day keeps the P45 away.” Decades later, I still feel a slight shiver when I hear those words. Behind that brutal sales mantra was a relentless focus on the fundamentals of advertising: circulation, coverage and reach.

Back then, we had a clever way of making advertising more relevant. Certain pages were tailored to different regions of the UK, allowing local businesses to advertise alongside the newspaper's wider editorial coverage. Someone elsewhere could be reading the same newspaper but seeing a different advertisement.

A futurist once told me that to understand where an industry is going, you should first understand where it has come from. The principle behind those regional pages remains relevant today. We've always tried to put the right messages in front of the right people. What has changed is how much we can understand about what happens next.

In print, circulation told us how many copies were sold or distributed, and readership research helped estimate who was reading them. But we couldn't know which articles caught someone's attention, how long they spent reading or whether they returned to a particular subject. Today we have extraordinary amounts of data, yet I wonder whether we've confused the ability to measure something with the value of measuring it.

Knowing your audience isn't the same as understanding it

Most B2B publishers specialise in a particular market. For us, it's HR. We know who our audience is, and so do many of our competitors. With the right tools, most organisations can identify the same HR directors, CHROs and senior professionals. But identifying an audience and distributing a message to it isn't the same as reaching people with something they find relevant.

Marketing teams spend considerable time defining their ideal customer profiles around job titles, company size, sector and geography. All sensible starting points, but they tell us remarkably little about what those people are interested in, what problems they're trying to solve or when those issues become important to them. Too often, we decide who we want to reach and then make assumptions about what will resonate.

We see this in our own audience data. Learning and development professionals demonstrate particularly strong engagement with AI-related content. Yet a client offering AI education and training wanted to target talent attraction professionals exclusively, believing they were the end users of its solution. What they overlooked was the role of learning and development teams in evaluating new technologies and supporting their adoption. Our audience intelligence revealed an engaged group outside the client's chosen audience.

We see something similar when suppliers want to reach CHROs. Our data shows that strategy and leadership content is particularly effective at engaging these senior executives. Yet clients frequently approach them with messaging focused on operational features rather than the strategic issues those leaders are responsible for. A product may be relevant to a CHRO, but that doesn't mean the way it's presented will capture their attention.

Understanding audience behaviour matters as much as knowing job titles. It helps us recognise what makes a message relevant, and that interested audiences aren't always where we expect to find them.

When does data become commercially valuable?

At the start of my career, circulation figures were one of the principal measures of a publisher's value to advertisers. Today, they've been joined by Google Analytics, open rates, click-through rates, impressions and bounce rates. We have more numbers than ever, but how much do they really tell us?

I've always believed that if you can't use data to make a business decision, you should question why you're collecting it in the first place. We spend an extraordinary amount of time reporting what happened, but far less time asking what we've learnt and what we should do differently.

Take email marketing. We can report how many people received a campaign, opened it or clicked, but what attracted their attention? Which readers responded and did they explore further? Clients frequently quote article impressions as evidence of success, but with automated traffic complicating measurement, how many represented genuine readers, and what did they do next?

At HR Grapevine, we're interested in the behaviour behind those numbers. Which issues attract particular audiences? Are they exploring related subjects? Are they returning? Our editorial expertise helps us understand the issues affecting HR, while our audience intelligence shows us how different groups of readers respond.

We see the value of this in our client email campaigns. Sending to a broadly engaged HR audience can produce good results, but identifying readers who have already demonstrated interest in a relevant subject can produce considerably stronger engagement. We can make campaigns more effective while protecting our relationship with readers, rather than simply increasing email volumes.

Turning audience intelligence into commercial value

Brand visibility and reach remain important. Broad exposure helps establish recognition, even among people who aren't actively looking for a solution. But as audiences begin exploring particular subjects, relevance becomes increasingly valuable. Anyone can glance at an advertisement or click on a headline. It takes curiosity to explore further and genuine interest to keep returning.

Someone reading an article demonstrates an initial interest in the subject, but one interaction doesn't establish a pattern. When that reader explores related content, we begin to understand more about the depth of their interest. By introducing further relevant articles, ideas and expertise, we can encourage that engagement to develop rather than treating every interaction as an isolated event.

This matters because B2B buying decisions can take months, sometimes years. Long before an organisation is ready to purchase, the people involved may be educating themselves about the market, exploring different approaches and becoming familiar with suppliers. Relationships develop over time, often long before a supplier knows someone is interested.

For me, this is where HR Grapevine offers something particularly valuable. We enable clients to become part of that engagement as it develops, introducing relevant content to readers already exploring the issues their businesses address.

Through our engagement programmes, qualifying contacts can become part of a supplier's own demand generation activity, subject to the appropriate data protection requirements. Suppliers can then continue building relationships with audiences who have already demonstrated meaningful engagement.

We're not claiming that engagement is purchase intent, or that every interested reader is a prospective customer. But we are giving suppliers an opportunity to participate earlier in the learning process, building familiarity and developing future demand rather than waiting for someone to identify themselves as ready to buy.

Why the HR publisher you choose matters

Two publishers may offer similar distribution figures, but that doesn't mean they understand their audiences equally well or can use that understanding to improve a campaign. At HR Grapevine, we combine established reach, editorial expertise and audience intelligence to help clients participate in the engagement already taking place across our readership.

When I started at The Observer, circulation, coverage and reach were the measures we lived by. They still matter. But today we can go further, understanding how audiences engage, recognising where interest is developing and helping advertisers become part of that relationship.

The real value of audience intelligence isn't simply what a publisher knows about its readers. It's what that knowledge enables its advertisers to achieve.

Read more

All insights

Talk to us about your next campaign

Tell us your marketing objectives and we'll help you build a campaign that reaches the right people.